Need for reorganization in agrucultural extension services in Turkey
2007, Journal of Applied Sciences Research
Abstract
Turkish agricultural extension system is an extension conducted by the public where the traditional extension approach is in practice. Extension within this system is organized within the structure of Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs (MARA) in a central understanding from Ankara to village groups. However, the effectiveness of public extension has gradually decreased in recent years. Reasons such as budget tightness, uncertainties in extension policy, low number of extension personnel and imbalances in distribution, lack of motivation, insufficient coordination with research organizations etc. have regressed public extension. Public extension has to be improved and reorganized because Turkish farmers have low-level incomes and face difficulties in accessing information. Development of the "Project for Support to Village Focused Agricultural Production" agricultural consultancy started in 2004 is important for farmers' access to information. Resources allocated for extension at MARA have to be increased, emphasis has to be put on in-house training efforts aimed at extension personnel and it has to be ensured that farmers contribute at all stages of the extension. Formation of an independent Agricultural Extension Directorate is another way for making the system more effective. Besides, private extension has to be supported, giving chance for newly graduate Agricultural Engineers.
Key takeaways
AI
AI
- Turkish agricultural extension services require reorganization due to declining effectiveness and budget constraints.
- Farmers face challenges accessing information, requiring improved public extension and private sector support.
- The 'Project for Support to Village Focused Agricultural Production' launched in 2004 aims to enhance farmer knowledge access.
- A proposed independent Agricultural Extension Directorate could centralize and improve coordination of extension activities.
- Agricultural extension must adapt to local needs rather than using a one-size-fits-all approach.
References (27)
- Ameur, C., 1994. Agricultural extension: a step beyond the next step. World Bank Technical Paper No. 247. The World Bank, Washington, DC.
- Bajwa, R., 2004. "Agricultural extension and the role of the private sector in Pakistan" 4 th International Crop Science Congress, Brisbane, Australia, 26 Sep -1 Oct 2004.
- Gunaydýn, G., 2006. Kuresellesen Piyasa, Yoksullasan Koylu, Ankara, Turkey. URL: http://www.zmo.org.tr/odamiz/rapor_03.php.
- Dinar, A. and G. Keynan, 2000. "The cost and performance of paid agricultural extension services", Policy Research Working Papers, Edition No.1931, The World Bank, Washington, D.C., pp: 36.
- Kiymaz, T., 2000. AB ve Turkiye'de Temel Urunlerde (Hububat, Seker, Sut) Uygulanan Tarimsal Destekleme Politikalari ve Bunlarin Hammadde Temini Acisindan Gida Sanayiine Etkileri, Yayinlanmamýs Uzmanlik Tezi, DPT, Ankara, Turkey, pp: 64.
- Kýlýncer, N., S. Anýl, S. Erkal, O. Karaca and U. Kaya, 2005. Tarimsal Arastirmalarda Oncelik ve Stratejiler. Turkiye Ziraat Muhendisligi VI.Teknik Kongresi, TMMOB, 2.Cilt, Ankara, Turkey, pp: 1097-1108.
- Kleps, C. and C. Absher, 1997. Information Technologies Used In Extension Services Of Some Central And Eastern European Countries and USA", First European Conference for Information Technology in Agriculture, Copenhagen, 15-18 June, 1997.
- Kumuk, T. and C. Talug, 1996. "Turk Tarimsal Yayim Sisteminde Degisim Ihtiyaci", Turkiye 2.Tarim Ekonomisi Kongresi, 2.Cilt, 4-6 September 1996, Adana, Turkey.
- Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, 2004. II.Agricultural Council, IX.Komisyon Raporu, Tarimsal Ögretim Egitim Yayim ve AR-GE, Ankara,Turkey.
- Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs, 2006. URL:http//www.tarim.gov.tr URL:http//www.tagem.gov.tr URL:http//www.tedgem.gov.tr
- Olgun, A., 1997. "The Needed Change In Agricultural Extension With Customs Union Agreement In Turkey". 13 European Seminar on th Extension Education, August 31-September 6, Ireland, pp: 374.
- Ozat, H.E., 2006. "Tarimsal Yayimda Ozel Danýsmanlýk Sistemlerinin Gelistirilmesi Acisindan KOY-MER Projesinin Gelecegi, Ankara, Turkey. URL: http://www.tarim.gen.tr/ web/articles.asp?id=296
- Ozkaya, T. and A. Olgun, 1993. "The Research and Extension Relations In Turkey" 11 European th Seminar on Extension Education, August 30- September 4,Denmark, pp: 155.
- Ozkaya, T., 1998. "Turkiye'de Kirsal Kalkinma Ile Tarimsal Yayim Sistemi Ýcin Bir Reform Onerisi", Turkiye 3.Tarim Ekonomisi Kongresi, T.C Ziraat Bankasý Kultur Yayini No:35, 7-9 Ekim 1998, Ankara, Turkey.
- Ozkaya, T., I.C. Ceylan, Y. Aktas, F. Selli and F. Pezikoglu, 2005. "Tarýmsal Yayým Hizmetleri ve Organizasyonu", Turkiye Ziraat Muhendisligi VI. Teknik Kongresi, 2. Cilt, 3-7 January 2005, Ankara, Turkey.
- Qumar, M.K., 2000. Agricultural Extension at the Turn of the Millennium: Trends and Challenges. Human Resources in Agricultural and Rural Development. Rome: Food and Agricultural Organization.
- Rivera, W., 1992. Global Trends in Extension Privatization. Journal of Extension, [on line]. Available at www: http://joe.org/1992
- Rivera, W.M., 1996. Agricultural Extension in Transition Worldwide: Structural, Financial and Managerial Strategies for Improving Agricultural Extension. Public Administration and Development. Vol. 16: 151-161.
- Rolling, N., 1988. Extension science. University Press, Cambridge.
- Sadighi, H., 2001. Organization Management System Affecting Extension Professionals' Motivation. Iran Agricultural Research, 20: 107-120.
- Sadighi, H., 2004. Agricultural Extension Privatization: An Analysis of Different Financing Schemes, AIAEE 2004 Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference Dublin, Ireland.
- Talug, C. and H. Tatlidil, 1986. "Tarimsal Yayim Hizmetlerinin Duzenlenmesi", Güneydogu Anadolu Projesi Tarimsal Kalkinma Simpozyumu, 18-21 November 1986, Ankara, Turkey.
- Talug, C., 1992. Arastirma-Teknoloji Politikalari Paneli. Tarim Haftasi 92 Sempozyumu. TMMOB Ziraat Muhendisleri Odasi 2000'li Yillara Dogru Türkiye Tarimi 7-10 Ocak 1992. Milli Kütüphane. Ankara, Turkey, pp: 554-556.
- Umali-Deininger, D., 1997. "Public and Private Agricultural Extension: Partners or Rivals?", The World Bank Research Observer, vol. 12.no. 2 (August 1997), pp: 203-24.
- Van Den Ban, A.W. and Hawkins, 1996, Agricultural Extension, Blackwell Science Ltd Pub., Oxford, pp: 256-258.
- World Bank, 2000, "Turkey-Agricultural Reform Implementation Project", PID9405 Report. P.1-8. http://www-wds.worldbank.org/servlet/ WDSContentServer/WDSP/IB/2000/ 08/18
- Yurttas, Z. and O. Yavuz, 2001. "Sustainability in Agricultural Extension and Rural Development A Case Study in Turkey", 15 European Seminar of th Extension Education (ESEE), August 27-31 ,2001, st Wageningen, The Natherlands.
Nuray KIZILASLAN