A GLOBAL STREAM FROM ADVERSARIAL JUSTICE TO NON-ADVERSARIAL JUSTICE: IS THERE A TENDENCY TO INQUISITORIAL TRADITION IN THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURE OF THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT?
Yazarlar (1)
Dr. Öğr. Üyesi Sercan TOKDEMİR
Tokat Gaziosmanpaşa Üniversitesi, Türkiye
| Makale Türü | Özgün Makale |
| Makale Alt Türü | Diğer hakemli uluslarası dergilerde yayınlanan tam makale |
| Dergi Adı | Law and Justice Review |
| Dergi ISSN | 1309-9485 |
| Dergi Tarandığı Indeksler | Art Index (Art Research Database, EBSCO) |
| Makale Dili | İngilizce |
| Basım Tarihi | 07-2023 |
| Cilt No | 14 |
| Sayı | 26 |
| Sayfalar | 15 / 48 |
| Makale Linki | https://lawandjustice.taa.gov.tr/yuklenenler/dosyalar/dergiler/law/law-26/a73da52f-c795-4e01-ae5e-5b427f3ac2aa-2--laj-78-sercan-tokdemir.pdf |
| Özet |
| This paper is divided into two main parts. In the first part, criminal procedural models named as inquisitorial and adversarial procedural systems and the convergence of them are analysed with a comparative perspective. In the second part, our focus will be on the criminal procedural system of the International Criminal Court (ICC). In this paper, the principal criminal procedural systems, which are adversarial system based on common law and inquisitorial system based on civil law, are examined in international courts, especially in the ICC, on a global scale concerning transitions between those traditions. Our purpose is to find an answer to the following question: To what extent is there a “drift” towards more inquisitorial justice at the ICC? To answer this question, one needs to begin with taking a closer look at the concepts of adversariality and inquisitoriality. Our aim is not only to examine the criminal procedural systems, but also to ascertain a functional and effective model considering domestic approaches. The paper puts forward to claim that a more effective criminal procedure model could be created in the cooperation of constituents in international criminal procedure. The unification of constituents in the criminal proceedings demonstrate that the court is not a battleground as in adversarial-common courts; on the contrary, the constituents in the proceedings act with a team spirit. Eventually, it seems that such a criminal procedure at the international level could be exercised within an inquisitorial tradition, which is seen as a more functional model taking into account particularly political and social global developments. |
| Anahtar Kelimeler |
| Criminal Procedural System | Inquisitorial Justice | Adversarial Justice | Judge | Prosecutor | Victim | Restorative Justice |
